Over the Rainbow

What the Pride flag says about the gentrification of queer politics 

I’ll admit it: I’m over the rainbow.

This month, people around the world unfurled its colours in honour of Pride Month, and the anniversary of the 28 June 1969 Stonewall Riots that sparked the Gay Liberation Movement. Since Gilbert Baker introduced it at the 1977 Liberation Day March in New York City, the Rainbow flag (also known as the Pride flag) has been a symbol of difference in sexual orientation and gender identity, spangling the windows of gay bars and the walls of LGBT service organizations, waved at protests in Moscow and Nairobi, and projected onto the facade of the White House. It is a monolithic, global symbol and a powerfully blunt metaphor: the spectrum of light – red, orange, yellow, green, blue, violet – mirrors the span of human diversity.

Pride parade, New York, 25 June 2017. Photograph: Dennis Van Tine/starmaxinc.com/Starmax/PA Images, All Rights Reserved

Pride parade, New York, 25 June 2017. Photograph: Dennis Van Tine/starmaxinc.com/Starmax/PA Images, All Rights Reserved

Pride parade, New York, 25 June 2017. Photograph: Dennis Van Tine/starmaxinc.com/Starmax/PA Images, All Rights Reserved

I’m over the rainbow, though – at least the one we’ve come to know these past few years, as gay marriage became law in the US and it became popular to publicly declare a policy of acceptance. Since then, the rainbow flag has become a mainstay of corporate advertising targeted towards LGBT (particularly white, gay male) consumers – a form of appropriation that profits from queer politics. Large, exploitative companies – real estate firms that refuse to rent to transgender people, or banks that sell junk loans to lower income queer people of colour, for instance – employ Baker's banner to ‘pinkwash’ their predatory practices, or conceal discrimination beneath a shallow veneer of tolerance.

Last weekend’s New York Pride Parade was sponsored by Wells Fargo, a backer of the Keystone XL Pipeline that has desecrated indigenous land and threatens local water sources in the Dakotas; most recently, the bank has been embroiled in a scandal about its predatory sales practices. Deutsche Bank, another sponsor, was revealed last year to have laundered billions of dollars for Vladimir Putin and the oligarchs running his repressive, homophobic regime. Co-sponsor Coca-Cola is notorious for privatising water resources in India, resulting in deadly scarcities and environmental degradation; 2,000 African-American employees in the US sued the company for discrimination in 2000. Dow Chemical was a sponsor of last weekend’s Mexico City Pride Parade; earlier this month, a Michigan court held the producer of napalm responsible for dumping toxic chemicals in local rivers for more than two decades.

Environmental and economic justice, health and human prosperity – what values could be more fundamental to a self-empowered queer community? These are, in fact, the values to which Baker’s flag refers: red stands for life, orange for healing, yellow for sunlight, green for nature, blue for serenity and purple for spirit. The original flag included two additional colours, pink for sex and violet for art, the most self-affirming tools of queer subversion. They were allegedly dropped due to production costs, but disappeared when the flag achieved widespread adoption; I can’t help but wonder if our most radical values were gentrified from our own vocabulary.

Star-spangled rainbow flag. Photograph: Wikimedia Commons

Star-spangled rainbow flag. Photograph: Wikimedia Commons

Star-spangled rainbow flag. Photograph: Wikimedia Commons

Cozying up to corporations has obvious benefits: today’s Pride celebrations are awash with giveaways, cheaply manufactured freebies and flashy displays. I saw children in the streets of Greenwich Village waving Pride flags emblazoned with Deutsche Bank’s logo, and crowds queuing for complimentary tubes of rainbow Colgate toothpaste. The effect of all this corporate propaganda is not to correct economic abuses and affirm basic respect for human rights, but to turn LGBT people into walking billboards for brands that are structurally racist, sexist and homophobic. It has made us unwitting accomplices to our own continued marginalisation. We paint ourselves with pride while permitting a public shame.

I’m over the rainbow, that corporate logo – the symbol we sold for a dime.

On 14 June, Flag Day, the City of Philadelphia unveiled its own newly designed Pride flag, with two additional stripes of black and brown, to acknowledge the contributions – and ongoing marginalisation – of queer people of colour. As news of the flag spread over the internet, rancorous debate ensued, between one camp that deemed it an unnecessary change of a supposedly sacred, universal symbol, and another eager to redress the persistence of white supremacy in the LGBT community. Critics of the flag who claimed it had failed its universal credo were right: it can no longer justly represent queer people of colour anymore than Wells Fargo can. But critics of those critics also had a point: amending the flag is a faulty fix, like taking an aspirin to cure appendicitis.

From feudal coats-of-arms to our modern-day standards, flags have always been symbols of domination; their form was developed in wartime, and later colonised both earthly and lunar soil. Even when banners were stitched and hoisted by revolutionary factions, progressive organisations or other radical groups, they maintained a social separatism that fueled our worst clannish impulses. Human beings learned to be proud for belonging to clubs that did not permit certain others to join them.

For many around the world, the US flag represents the ideals of democracy and freedom of expression; but for many others, it represents military aggression and economic imperialism. The latter group are why I never pin it to my lapel or wear it on a t-shirt, even though I recognise its multivalence. The problem would not be solved by amending its design, but rather by limiting its chauvinistic display. Germans learned this lesson after the Second World War, and it’s rare to see the Bundesflagge in public, outside of national football matches.

Marilyn Minter, RESIST FLAG, 2017. Photo: Guillaume Ziccarelli. Courtesy: Creative Time

Marilyn Minter, RESIST FLAG, 2017. Photo: Guillaume Ziccarelli. Courtesy: Creative Time

Marilyn Minter, RESIST FLAG, 2017. Photo: Guillaume Ziccarelli. Courtesy: Creative Time

The Pride flag is no different. Though its colours may signal inclusivity, it has an immediate semiotic function like any other, producing feelings of identification for some and estrangement for others. And when these feelings already exist, it deepens the divide, drawing lines of strict solidarity around a community with porous borders. Even well-intentioned forms of solidarity can declare unity where none exists, and ignore the complicated specificities of intersectional experience. As Paul Clinton wrote in the April 2017 issue of frieze, ‘Don’t get personal, get structural; rather than mobilizing one identity or person against another, question the very logic of identification or of political community.’

Let’s get over the rainbow, and over its reductivist charge. Whatever lies beyond will be harder to commodify and corporatize. Most importantly, it will belong to us all.

Main image: Pride parade in Toronto, 25 June 2017. Photograph: Mark Blinch/The Canadian Press/PA Images, All Rights Reserved

Evan Moffitt is assistant editor of frieze, based in New York, USA. 

Most Read

A year marked by new visualizations, both controversial and celebrated, of the black body
The Courtauld Gallery, London, UK
Openings at the new ICA, The Bass and PAMM played out against a backdrop of geographic uncanniness and atmospheric...
With the recent razing of suburban slums, tightening censorship and the sad passing of Geng Jianyi, a year of...
Nicholas Mangan, Ancient Lights (detail), 2015, two-screen installation, solar panels, batteries, projectors powered by solar energy, dimensions variable. Courtesy: the artist, Sutton Gallery, Melbourne, Hopkinson Mossman, Auckland and Labor, Mexico
At once stagnant and dynamic, politically tense and blissfully buoyant, the French capital was a strange place to be...
From victims of Hurricane Harvey to the music of Roger Waters, 2017 has been full of renewed debate around support for...
In further news: MOCA Detroit suspends Jens Hoffmann after harassment allegations; Met refuses to remove ‘suggestive’...
‘Conflicts of interest’ may have cost Beatrix Ruf her Stedelijk job but the problem doesn’t just lie with individuals...
Her work animates the consequences of our colonial history and the construction of identity politics: in a divided...
France's President Emmanuel Macron meets Burkina Faso's President Roch Marc Christian Kabore at the Presidential Palace in Burkina Faso on November 28, 2017. Courtesy: LUDOVIC MARIN/AFP/Getty Images
The French President’s recent comments hint at a dubious politics: using art restitution as a stopgap to France’s...
More from today’s Briefing: protesting Raghubir Singh; documenta artists defend exhibition (again); Enrico Castellani (...
Tiffany and Co., Sterling Silver Paper Cup, 2017, from the ‘Everyday Objects’ collection. Courtesy: Tiffany and Co., New York
Tiffany & Co.’s new range of gift objects and the shifting meaning of the ‘everyday’
From Hannah Black to Not Surprised, the changes demanded by today’s letter writers are still a long way from being...
Johan Grimonprez, Shadow World, 2016, film still. Courtesy: the artist, Sean Kelly Gallery, New York, Galerie Kamel Mennour, Paris, Flatland Gallery, Amsterdam, Ronald Reagan Presidential Library, Simi Valley, Louverture Films, Dillywood and Shadow World inc., New York
Johan Grimonprez’s recent films explore the mechanisms of the arms trade
A pivot to glass by the sculptor shows an attempt to see hope through political disillusionment
In further news: initiative for museum staff diversity; Gwangju Biennale's 2018 curators; Jens Hoffmann clarifies Front...
Ahead of Manifesta’s opening in Palermo next summer, the importance of remembering an alternative Mediterranean...
Inverting the gaze: real life biography, game play fantasy and Frantz Fanon combine in the British artist’s films
Old Food, 2017, production still. Courtesy: the artist, Galerie Isabella Bortolozzi, Berlin, Cabinet Gallery, London, Gavin Brown’s Enterprise, New York and Rome, and dépendance, Brussels
Helen Marten responds to Ed Atkins’s new work, Old Food, currently showing at Martin-Gropius-Bau, Berlin
Elsewhere: activists protest AfD with Holocaust Memorial replica; censorship at Kuala Lumpur Biennale; Venice Biennale'...
Twenty years after the First Cyberfeminist International at Documenta X, what does Cyberfeminism look like in...
Thinking about propaganda, palimpsests, and a presentation of Tino Sehgal works in Moscow
As London's Architectural Association celebrates 100 years of female students, rediscovering the city designed by women
Lin May Saeed, Lobster, 2017. Metal, 11 x 24 x 14.5 cm. Courtesy: the artist, Nicolas Krupp, Basel, Jacky Strenz, Frankfurt am Main and Lulu, Mexico City
Lulu, Mexico City, Mexico
For the 6th Amsterdam Art Weekend, our picks of the best shows and events across the Dutch capital
Highlights of the shows included in the third iteration of Dublin Gallery Weekend
An interview with Casco – Office for Art, Design and Theory, on new ways for art institutions to work
With her current show at Studio_Leigh, London, the artist shares some important images
Recent instances of censorship show an emboldened far right attacking the arts, queer identity and more: artists,...
The staggering price reached by Salvator Mundi prompts the question: what are you really buying when you buy an artwork?
Wong Kar-wai, Happy Together, 1997, film still. Courtesy: the artist and Alamy 
From the new issue of frieze: Changes in urban cultures and queer aesthetics across the Sinosphere 
On the occasion of two UK solo exhibitions, the British artist reflects on the art and events that have shaped her...

Latest Magazines

frieze magazine

October 2017

frieze magazine

November - December 2017

frieze magazine

January - February 2018